Homes for Sale in Winona Lake, Indiana

The town of Winona Lake is a pocket community of approximately 5,000 people within the larger city of Warsaw. Winona is well known for it’s many artisan shops, boutiques and restaurants located in the heart of “The Village”. The town attracts tourists from all over the Midwest for it’s weekend art festivals, fat & skinny tire festival, network of hiking and biking trails, and historic Billy Sunday Museum. Winona Lake is also the home to Grace College and many of the alumni whose hearts were captivated by the beauty of this small town and decided to make it their permanent residence.

It goes without saying that Winona Lake itself is a main attraction of this small town. The lake is 571 acres in total and hosts some of the most spectacular sunsets you will ever see. Every 4th of July residents and visitors also enjoy a full blown display of fireworks over the lake. Being an all-sport lake, it is excellent for boating, water-skiing, kayaking and fishing, where you can expect to catch bluegill, catfish, bass, sunfish and perch. The Lake has an average depth of 30 feet and a maximum depth of 79 feet. 

Winona Lake is bordered on the east by a park, splash pad and public beach where you will find lots of families enjoying the outdoors and swimming all summer long. The east side is also where you will find ten miles of wooded hiking and biking trails. Because it is one of the most coveted lakes in all of Kosciusko County, lakefront properties are harder to come by. Homes along the lake range from small cottages to large lakeside estates.

Property values in Winona Lake have been on a steady incline since the 1980s. Many of the homes on the island and in the village have been newly renovated, though there are still a handful of homes in need of fixing up. Further out of Winona proper you will find the neighborhoods of Southtown, Heritage Lake Park, Lexington Manor, Stonehenge, and a recent development of new homes in Tuscany.

Winona Lake has a lot to offer and is a highly desirable place to be. As a former resident of Winona proper for nearly a decade, I give it a hearty endorsement.

Market Overview

Winona Lake, IN Real Estate Statistics

Median Home Price

$219,900

Average Home Sale Price

N/A

Median Price Per Sqft

$119

Median Rent

$781

Days on Market

77

Annual Appreciation

-10.1%

What's To Love

What's Not To Love

Is it for me?

Who is this neighborhood for

Nature lovers, outdoorsy people, artisans and young trend setters as well as those who enjoy community events, lake living, boutique shopping and ridiculously good food.

Find Your Home

Latest homes for sale in Winona Lake

36
Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

$319,900

1409 Stratford Drive

Winona Lake, IN, 46590
Beds4Baths3SqFt2,570MLS#202215532
36
Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

$315,000

1985 Troon Road

Winona Lake, IN, 46590
Beds3Baths2SqFt1,637MLS#202217155
36
Active

$286,125

2404 Winona Avenue 3

Winona Lake, IN, 46590
Beds2Baths1SqFt1,175MLS#202218052
18
Cont-AccptngBackupOffers

$239,900

1431 Sunset Drive

Winona Lake, IN, 46590
Beds3Baths2SqFt1,484MLS#202201854
Amy Evans

Your Kosciusko County Realtor

Why am I a real estate agent? Real estate is much more to me than a job. It is what I love, it is my investment vehicle of choice, it is the area of expertise that I can offer to others, and it is the perfect blend of my passions: education, houses, and serving others. If you are thinking about buying or selling and would like to discuss your goals, please reach out to me today!

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Winona Lake, IN

Population

4,860

Median Age

33

Median Household Income

$62,813

Households

1,774

Average Household Size

2.33

Cost of Living Score

83

Entertainment

Things to do in Winona Lake

Stonehenge Golf

This stunning golf course is an excellent area to play golf.

Shop the Village

Shop, dine, and have fun at The Village at Winona, a historic shopping district located in a scenic lakeside setting.

Limitless Park and K21 Splash Pad

An exciting water park where residents often enjoy visiting to beat the heat.

Heritage Trail

A lovely lake trail where residents can relax and be one with nature.

Education

Schools in Winona Lake

School Name
Grades
Admission
Jefferson Elementary School
K – 5
Public
Eisenhower Elementary
K – 5
Public
Lakeview Middle School
6 – 8
Public
Edgewood Middle School
6 – 8
Public
Warsaw High School
9 – 12
Public
On the map

Winona Lake Map

Close Menu
Home
Search
Call
Account
Close Menu