Homes for Sale in Nappanee, Indiana

Nappanee is located in the heart of Amish Country and is currently the 6th largest Amish settlement in the country. Tourists flock to this area to visit Amish Acres, enjoy hearty home cooked meals, and shop hand-made furniture, woodworking and crafts. The popular Rise ‘n Roll Bakery certainly helped to put Nappanee on the map! Rise ‘n Roll donuts are so tasty (and addicting!) that they are lovingly referred to by locals as Amish Crack.

More than 80,000 people attend Nappanee’s annual Apple Festival on the 3rd week of each September. Named #1 in Indiana’s Top 10 Fall Festivals, the event kicks off each year with the baking of a 7 foot apple pie which is then sliced into 800 pieces and divvied up among attendees. 

Historically Nappanee was founded as a railroad town whose first real industry was from the sawmill, later followed by box making, furniture making and potato and onion farming. Today, Nappanee is well known for its thriving RV manufacturing industry as well as its custom furniture and cabinet making industries.

Nappanee is a “big small town”. It’s population hovers around 13,000 people spread out among 4,800 houses and several acres. The median home value is $179,000. It is a family friendly community with strong moral fiber as its backbone. 

Market Overview

Nappanee, IN Real Estate Statistics

Median Home Price

$171,900

Average Home Sale Price

$211,038

Median Price Per Sqft

$110

Median Rent

$829

Days on Market

33

Annual Appreciation

7.5%

What's To Love

What's Not To Love

Is it for me?

Who is this neighborhood for

People who value a strong sense of community, hard work, peaceful living, home cooked meals, and honest dealing with their neighbors.

Find Your Home

Latest homes for sale in Nappanee

36
Open House
Active

$385,000

719 Mohawk Drive

Nappanee, IN, 46550
Beds4Baths4SqFt3,367MLS#202237392
23
Active

$179,000

756 E John Street

Nappanee, IN, 46550
Beds2Baths2SqFt1,450MLS#202239787
Amy Evans

Your Kosciusko County Realtor

Why am I a real estate agent? Real estate is much more to me than a job. It is what I love, it is my investment vehicle of choice, it is the area of expertise that I can offer to others, and it is the perfect blend of my passions: education, houses, and serving others. If you are thinking about buying or selling and would like to discuss your goals, please reach out to me today!

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Nappanee, IN

Population

6,897

Median Age

34.9

Median Household Income

$55,125

Households

2,634

Average Household Size

2.67

Cost of Living Score

83.20

Entertainment

Things to do in Nappanee

Visit Amish Acres

An Amish farmstead that features a couple of restaurants and events center perfect for gatherings and weddings.

Shop Coppes Commons

Antique shopping center with various unique stores and other local businesses.

Eat Rise 'n Roll

Amish bakery serving freshly baked goods cooked with traditional Amish tools and fresh ingredients.

Take the Heritage Trail

A lovely driving tour of various iconic sites and landmarks throughout the community.

Education

Schools in Nappanee

School Name
Grades
Admission
Woodview Elementary School
K – 5
Public
Nappanee Elementary School
K – 5
Public
Wakarusa Elementary School
K – 5
Public
NorthWood Middle School
6 – 8
Public
NorthWood High School
9 – 12
Public
On the map

Nappanee Map