Homes for Sale in Mentone, Indiana

Mentone has declared itself the Egg Basket of the Midwest because of it’s sizeable contribution to the nation’s egg production. The town proudly displays the world’s largest egg, a giant concrete statue near the town center, and celebrates it’s heritage with the annual Egg Festival each June. The town in also know for its aircraft museum located just off of State Rd 25.

Mentone attracts residents who love small town, quiet living and a home-grown farm feel. The town has a population of just over 1000 people and 460 homes. The average price point for a home in town is $90,000, but you can also expect to find properties outside of town that come with acreage to raise animals, hunt, fish and farm anywhere from $150,000-$300,000. 

Many who live in Mentone commute to the larger surrounding towns for employment such as Warsaw, Rochester, Nappanee, and Syracuse, but they choose to live in Mentone because it offers the quietude and country feel they prefer. Residents are hardworking, do-it-yourselfers who are also incredibly friendly and generous people. You may not have many neighbors here, but the ones you do have are pure gold.

Market Overview

Mentone, IN Real Estate Statistics

Median Home Price

$83,000

Average Home Sale Price

$129,000

Median Price Per Sqft

$69

Median Rent

$681

Days on Market

41

Annual Appreciation

19.7%

What's To Love

What's Not To Love

Is it for me?

Who is this neighborhood for

People who value hard work, land to raise kids or animals (or both!), small and tight-knit community, quiet neighbors and a simpler lifestyle.

Find Your Home

Latest homes for sale in Mentone

33
Active

$169,900

101 Harrison Street E

Mentone, IN, 46539
Beds4Baths2SqFt1,500MLS#202214183
23
Active

$135,500

310 Broadway Street N

Mentone, IN, 46539
Beds3Baths1SqFt1,450MLS#202216093
Amy Evans

Your Kosciusko County Realtor

Why am I a real estate agent? Real estate is much more to me than a job. It is what I love, it is my investment vehicle of choice, it is the area of expertise that I can offer to others, and it is the perfect blend of my passions: education, houses, and serving others. If you are thinking about buying or selling and would like to discuss your goals, please reach out to me today!

Meet the locals

Who Lives in Mentone, IN

Population

954

Median Age

33.4

Median Household Income

$57,361

Households

465

Average Household Size

2.6

Cost of Living Score

74.70

Entertainment

Things to do in Mentone

Egg Festival

As the self-proclaimed Egg Basket of the Midwest, Mentone hosts a regular festival to commemorate this achievement.

Eat at Bourbon St Pizza

Local pizza store serving gourmet pies baked with fresh ingredients and served with other delicious sides and drinks.

Shooting Range

Local gun store and range selling firearms, ammunition, and accessories.

Bell Aircraft Museum

Explore the beauty of aircrafts ever since it began by visiting this lovely museum in the center of the town.

Education

Schools in Mentone

School Name
Grades
Admission
Mentone Elementary School
K – 5
Public
Tippecanoe Valley Middle School
6 – 8
Public
Tippecanoe Valley High School
9 – 12
Public
On the map

Mentone Map

Close Menu
Home
Search
Call
Account
Close Menu